Proudly serving Killearn, Midtown, SouthWood, Crawfordville, Havana, Quincy and the greater Tallahassee area. Made for The Sunshine State.

TallahasseeTopRated / Title & Escrow Companies

Best title and escrow companies in Tallahassee, FL

Verified Tallahassee title and escrow companies for title insurance, escrow, real estate closings, and lien searches - serving Killearn, Midtown, SouthWood, Crawfordville, Havana, Quincy and beyond.

Rankings updated September 2026 from Google ratings and review volume - not paid placement

How to pick a title and escrow company in Tallahassee

Ask who holds the escrow funds and how wire instructions are verified, then confirm any wiring email by phone using a number you looked up yourself. Wire fraud is the one mistake in a closing nobody can undo.

Searching for title and escrow companies near me in Tallahassee? Everyone ranked below serves Tallahassee and the surrounding neighborhoods, including Killearn, Midtown, SouthWood, Crawfordville, Havana, Quincy. Check the address and service area on a listing before you call, because the closest one is not always the one a search engine puts first.

How we rank these Tallahassee businesses

Today this order comes from public Google ratings and review volume, and nothing else.

A quality floor. At least a 4.0 rating and 15 or more reviews to be listed at all.
Confidence, not just stars. A thin rating gets pulled toward the typical rating for its own category, in proportion to how few reviews back it up; a well-reviewed rating is trusted almost entirely as is. A 4.9 from 7 reviews is a weaker claim than a 4.5 from 890, and the order says so.
Recent counts for more. A five star review from four years ago is not evidence about the crew working today.
One customer, one voice, and a burst of reviews in a single day counts for less than the same reviews earned over a month.
Local means local. A business has to actually serve Tallahassee to be listed here. We measure the distance from the business to the city and drop the ones that are really in another market, which is why you will not see a clinic an hour away sitting above the one down the road.
The ranked order is not for sale. No business can pay to move up in the numbered list. Every position in it is earned on public ratings and review volume and nothing else.
Featured is a labelled spotlight, not a rank. The starred card above the rankings is reserved for businesses that have recently joined Top Rated. A new client can be excellent and still have a short review history, and the numbers alone would bury them for months, so the spotlight gives them visibility while that history builds. It carries no position number, it never moves anyone in the numbered list below it, and it is clearly marked every time it appears. We also rotate it: promotions and seasonal events cycle different clients through the slot, so it is a turn in the spotlight rather than a permanent purchase.

What is changing. We are adding a second signal: reviews left here by customers whose job we can actually trace. It is built and published below so you can see it before it counts, and it is not part of the order yet. A review will count more when we can prove the job happened, not because it was left on our site.

How much each kind of review counts

1.6xVerified job
A Top Rated review from a customer whose job we can trace: we brokered the lead, the work was booked, and the review came after the job.
1.2xVerified account
A Top Rated review from a real, signed-in account that we cannot tie to a specific job.
1xGoogle
A public Google review. This is the baseline and it is not discounted.
0xUnverified
Anything we cannot stand behind. Shown if we show it, counts for nothing.

Still curious? The full methodology and the FAQ.

The full Tallahassee ranking

Show independents only

Peacock Title Inc Independent · Locally Owned

★★★★★ 5 · 27 Google reviews · 2932 Wellington Cir Ste B/201

View profile Call Website

Unclaimed - is this yours?

Owen Title Company Independent · Locally Owned

★★★★½ 4.8 · 87 Google reviews · 2865 Remington Green Cir #102

View profile Call Website

Unclaimed - is this yours?

Hayward Title Group Independent · Locally Owned

★★★★½ 4.8 · 52 Google reviews · 2121 Killarney Way # G

View profile Call Website

Unclaimed - is this yours?

Advantage Title Group, LLC Independent · Locally Owned

★★★★½ 4.5 · 22 Google reviews · 917 N. Monroe Street

View profile Call Website

Unclaimed - is this yours?

Tallahassee Title Group LLC Independent · Locally Owned

★★★★ 4.1 · 24 Google reviews · 1407 Piedmont Dr E A

View profile Call Website

Unclaimed - is this yours?

Title & Escrow Companies in Tallahassee: common questions

Who are the best title and escrow companies in Tallahassee?

Based on Google ratings and review volume as of September 2026, the top rated title and escrow companies in Tallahassee are Peacock Title Inc, Owen Title Company, Hayward Title Group. See the live ranked list, ratings, and contact details on this page.

How do I find title and escrow companies near me in Tallahassee?

Every company ranked on this page serves Tallahassee and the surrounding area, including Killearn, Midtown, SouthWood, Crawfordville, Havana, Quincy. Open any listing for its address, phone number and service area, then call the two or three closest to you. Distance is worth checking yourself: the nearest title and escrow company is not automatically the best one, so this page ranks on rating and review volume first and leaves proximity to you.

How do I choose a title and escrow company in Tallahassee?

Are you a top-rated Tallahassee pro?

Listings and claims are free. Early claimants receive Premium at no charge, a $297 value, after confirmation. No purchase is required.

Claim your free listing

Prefer to talk? Call or text the Top Rated directory on (813) 454-0813. This is our number, not the number of any business listed here.